354 The Making of a Conspiracy Theorist: The Fallacy of “Vote Harder” and Why There’s no Moving on From 2016
đ§š Chapter Title: The Making of a Conspiracy Theorist: The Fallacy of âVote Harderâ and Why Thereâs No Moving On From 2016
đ§ Setup Paragraph: Forgive and ForgetâAgain
It didnât take long. No sooner had Trumpâs coup failed than the Savvy Punditocracy began urging restraint. Donât prosecute. Donât investigate. Just move on.
Some said Trump wasnât guilty. Others said his behavior was âunprecedentedâ and therefore not illegal. Still others said he was guiltyâbut prosecuting him would be âdivisive.â
Even James Comeyâthe man who elected Trumpâargued against prosecution. Even President-Elect Biden, just days after defeating Trump, voiced his preference to let it go.
đ§± Sidebar: Et Tu, Comey?
Comey argued DOJ shouldnât prosecute Trumpâeven after J6.
âThe mission of the next attorney general must be fostering the trust of the American people.â â Saving Justice, Jan. 2021
But despite knowing Trump was a counterintelligence risk Comey soft-pedaled Russiagate. He weaponized Emailgate. And now he wanted bygones.
See Chapter: The Real Deep State is Republican
đ§ Modular Insert: President Joeâs First Mistake
Biden hadnât even entered the Oval Office when he signaled his preference to avoid Trump investigations.
âBiden hopes to avoid divisive Trump investigations, preferring unity.â â NBC News, Nov. 2020
In his first official act, he kept Christopher Wray as FBI Director. See Chapter: President Joeâs First Mistake
đ§ Section Title: No Moving On
Weâve seen this movie before. Forgive and forget. Donât stop thinking about tomorrow. But the past keeps repeating.
Nixon sabotaged LBJâs peace talks in 1968. Watergate wasnât just the break-inâit was the Canucks Letter, hand-delivered by a 19-year-old Roger Stone.
Nixon wanted McGovern. He got him as the Canucks letter drove Ed Muskie out of the race. And we moved on.
Carter pardoned G. Gordon Liddy in 1977. Clinton dropped Iran-Contra investigations in 1993. And the GOP thanked him by investigating imaginary Clinton crimes for seven years.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: The Institutionalist Reflex and the Marginalization Machine
Biden prides himself on being an âinstitutionalist.â But apparently that included watching his own son get railroaded. Hunter Biden wasnât asking for special treatment. He was asking not to be Ken Starred.
As I had observed many times over the many years of the fishing expedition into Hunter Biden-here I noted it X.
âThe Hunter Biden âinvestigationâ really has all the earmarks of Ken Starrâs Whitewater fiasco.â â Expand the Court on X
Merrick Garland, meanwhile, was too busy defending Trump in court against Peter Strzokâs lawsuit to notice Hunter was being Susan McDougaled. Actually, thatâs too charitableâGarland did notice. He just chose to keep David Weiss, Trumpâs handpicked prosecutor, while firing everyone else.
Weiss privately admitted that if Hunterâs last name were anything else, the case wouldnât have gone this far. Garland made him Special Counsel anyway.
Biden finally pardoned Hunter. But the only mistake was waiting so long. The institutionalist reflex cost his sonâand nearly cost the narrative.
đ§± Sidebar: The Real Deep Politics
In 2000, the GOP Supreme Court stole the White House from Clintonâs VP. We moved on. In 2001, we were told no one could have seen 9/11 coming. We moved on.
To question the official Cheney-Bush story of 9/11 is to be labeled a âconspiracy theorist.â Just like questioning the Warren Commission. Just like questioning Iran-Contra. Just like questioning Hunterâs prosecution.
But as Peter Dale Scott argues in Dallas â63, beneath electoral politics lies another layer: Deep Politics. The machinery behind the machinery.
See: Dallas â63: The First Deep State Revolt Against the White House
đ§ Modular Insert: The Savvy Marginalization Protocol
Ask too many inconvenient questions? Youâre a conspiracy theorist. Youâre not credible. You donât deserve answers.
Mike Isikoff calls it âoutlandish.â The Savvy call Seth Abramson âunhinged.â Jim Garrison was smeared by CIA-friendly journalists. His political career was destroyed. But he was right.
The Savvy laugh. The questions remain.
See: Destiny Betrayed by James DiEugenio
đ FN Cascade
Let me know when youâre ready to drop the next chunk. Weâre tunneling with rhythm, fire, and full philosophical clarity.
đ§ Section Title: The Commission That Wasnât
The 9/11 Commission had a problem. Its executive director, Philip Zelikow, was a close ally of Condoleezza Rice. He spoke with her during the investigation. He received calls from Karl Rove. He ordered his secretary to stop logging his calls.
Meanwhile, Dick Cheney personally called Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle to discourage the probe. He said it was âa very dangerous and time-consuming diversionâ.
The Commission made its conclusions before it began. Just like the Warren Commission 40 years earlier.
đ§± Sidebar: The Deep Stateâs Favorite GenreâLost Evidence
Cheney claimed he gave a shoot-down order on 9/11. But Flight 93 wasnât shot down. And Cheney had no legal authority to issue such an order.
He told Dan Quayle that in 1991. See: Angler: The Cheney Vice Presidency by Barton Gellman
Oswald was an FBI informant. His file was tampered with. Key documents vanished.
The Secret Service âlostâ all texts from January 5â6, 2021. DHS delayed oversight. The FBI ignored J6 warnings.
The Deep State didnât oppose Trump. It elected him.
đ§ Modular Insert: American Exceptionalism as Epistemic Shield
The Savvy consensus says: âWeâre an exceptional nation. Therefore, our leaders couldnât have done what the facts suggest.â
Cheneyâs shoot-down claim? Not questioned. Because questioning it would mean questioning American Exceptionalism.
The Warren Report? Sacred text. The 9/11 Report? Article of faith.
To question either is to disqualify yourself from polite society. Youâre not a citizen. Youâre a conspiracy theorist.
đ§ Section Title: Obamaâs Turn to Move On
Many of us who voted for Obama hoped for accountability. But he made his position clear before taking office.
âWe need to look forward as opposed to looking backwards.â â Obama, Jan. 2009
In April 2009, he doubled down:
âThis is a time for reflection, not retribution.â â CBS News
His aidesâRahm Emanuel, Robert Gibbsâpressured DOJ to drop investigations. The CIA opposed any review. Obama complied.
See: Glenn Greenwaldâs 2014 retrospective on Obamaâs whitewashing of Bush-era crimes
đ FN Cascade
Let me know when youâre ready to drop the next chunk. Weâre building a manuscript that doesnât just expose the Deep Stateâit documents its architecture.
đ§ Section Title: The Architecture of Immunity
On April 16, 2009, Obama formalized full-scale immunity for Bush-era torturers. If the torture was âauthorizedâ by DOJ memos, it was forgiven.
âThis is a time for reflection, not retribution.â â Obama, April 2009
Holder echoed the sentiment:
âIt would be unfair to prosecute dedicated men and women⊠for conduct sanctioned in advance.â â DOJ Statement
Accountability was rebranded as division. The rule of law was rebranded as partisan witch-hunts.
See:
đ§± Sidebar: The Deep State Doesnât Move On
Nixon sabotaged peace talks in 1968. We moved on. Reagan colluded with Iran in 1980. We moved on. Bush stole Florida in 2000. We moved on. Cheney ran the war machine from the shadows. We moved on.
Obama said:
âWe need to look forward as opposed to looking backwards.â â ABC News, Jan. 2009
Biden echoed the same tune in 2020. Trump refused to concede. Biden refused to investigate.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: Greenwaldâs Last Good Piece
Greenwaldâs 2012 piece was a blistering indictment of Obamaâs DOJ. But since then, heâs gone full anti-anti-Trump. He defended Bill Barrâs sabotage of the Stone conviction by citing⊠Bill Barrâs sabotage of Iran-Contra in 1990.
See Chapter: Useful Idiots
đ§ Section Title: No Bottom Without Truth
We now live in a country where a 13-year-old rape victim has fewer rights than her rapist. There is no bottom. There is no moving on without accountability. And no accountability without truth.
As Sarah Kendzior writes:
âThe truth is not a luxury. It is a necessity.â â They Knew: How a Culture of Conspiracy Keeps America Complacent
đ§ Section Title: The Radicalizing Election
For Krugman, 2000 was the radicalizing election. For me, it was 2016.
I saw the FBI elect Trump. I saw rogue agents leak to Julian Assange. I saw the machinery of sabotage in motion.
Thatâs when I became a âconspiracy theorist.â Or as Peter Dale Scott would say: I gained insight into Deep Politics.
See: Dallas â63: The First Deep State Revolt Against the White House by Peter Dale Scott
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: Vote Harder?
People have been voting hard. Clintonâs 1992 win felt like a turning point. Obamaâs 2008 margin was massive. Bidenâs 2020 win was a 7 million vote landslide.
But the machinery beneath the surfaceâthe Republican-dominated Deep Stateâkeeps grinding. Electoral victories are real. But theyâre not enough.
As Peter Dale Scott reminds us:
Electoral politics are one thing. Deep Politics are another.
đ§± Sidebar: The Electoral Mirage
Biden 2020: 7 million vote margin. Trump 2016: 3 million vote deficit. Both got 306 electoral votes.
Reagan 1980: 8.5 million vote margin â 489 EVs Clinton 1996: 8.3 million vote margin â 379 EVs Obama 2008: 9.5 million vote margin â 365 EVs Biden 2020: 7 million vote margin â 324 EVs
The GOPâs Electoral College advantage has grown dramatically. Small states, winner-take-all rules, and voter distribution skew the map.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Mirage of Realignment
Clintonâs 1992 win felt like a Democratic realignment. But the GOP took Congress in 1994. And spent five years trying to destroy him.
Clintonâs 1996 margin was larger than Reaganâs 1980. But Reagan got 489 EVs. Clinton got 379.
Obamaâs 2008 margin was the largest since LBJ. But the machinery of sabotage never stopped.
The vote margins are real. The process advantages are deeper.
đ§ CODA: Democracy Without Power Is Just Theater
The J6 Committee did great work. Trumpâs cabinet testified against him. Heâs been indicted four times on 91 counts.
But the Deep State still protects him. The FBI ignored J6 warnings. The Secret Service âlostâ all the texts. Off-duty cops joined the insurrection.
Netanyahu learned the lesson. Bibi was indicted. Then came 10/7. Now heâs back.
Trump sees it. Heâs watching. And heâs planning.
đ FN Cascade
Let me know when youâre ready to pick up tomorrow morning. Weâre scoring a movementâand this chapter is its overture. đŒđ„
đ§ Section Title: Vote Harder? We Did.
In the last eight presidential elections, Democrats won the popular vote seven times. Yet Republicans âwonâ the presidency three timesâtwice via the Electoral College, once via the Supreme Court.
In those three GOP administrations, five Supreme Court justices were confirmed. In the five Democratic administrations? Just three. And none shifted the ideological balance.
The GOPâs advantage isnât just electoral. Itâs structural. Electoral College. Senate distribution. Supreme Court pipeline.
See:
đ§± Sidebar: The Senate Doesnât Represent You
The GOP hasnât represented a majority of Americans in the Senate since 1996. Yet theyâve held power half the time since 2000. See:
Stephen Wolfâs analysis shows Democrats have received tens of millions more votes for Senate seats over the last 30 years. But thanks to small-state overrepresentation and the filibuster, the GOP still blocks most of the Democratic agenda.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Real Deep State
The FBI elected Trump. They leaked anti-Clinton material throughout 2016. They threatened to leak Huma Abedinâs emails to Wikileaks. They knew Trump was a counterintelligence risk. They did it anyway.
The Secret Service âlostâ all J6 texts. DHS delayed oversight. Off-duty cops joined the insurrection.
Everything old is new again. See: Chapter BarrâDurham Fiasco
đ§ Section Title: Goodbye to All That
For years, I drank the Savvy Kool-Aid. I believed conspiracies were âunpossible.â I thought JFK truthers were cranks. I laughed at anti-vaxxersâuntil they stopped being funny.
But then came 2016. I saw the FBI elect Trump. I saw the Peopleâs Will thwarted again. I saw the machinery of sabotage in motion.
Like Robert Graves, I said:
Goodbye to All That.
See:
đ§ CODA: The Savvy Creed
In the Savvy mainstream, a âconspiracy theoristâ is anyone who doubts American Exceptionalism. Anyone who thinks voting harder isnât enough. Anyone who asks:
Why does the minority keep winning?
The Savvy say:
âJust vote harder.â The People say: âWe did.â
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: Emailgate and the Erasure Machine
During the election, pundits couldnât stop talking about Hillaryâs emails. But after they caught their carâafter they defeated that uppity womanâthey dropped it overnight. Emailgate vanished. The hysteria was memoryholed.
The FBI elected Trump. The New York Times amplified it. And American Exceptionalism demanded we forget.
HRC didnât lose because of the emails. She lost because she didnât go to Michigan. Thatâs the Savvy story. Thatâs the lie.
đ§± Sidebar: The FBI Elected Trump. What Else Would They Do?
In 2016, the FBI threatened to leak Huma Abedinâs emails to Wikileaks. They knew Trump was a counterintelligence risk. They elected him anyway.
Vote Harder only makes sense in a functioning democracy. But our electoral process is structurally undemocratic:
- Electoral College
- Senate distribution
- Filibuster
- Supreme Court pipeline
- Redistricting
Reform isnât optional. Itâs existential.
đ§ Modular Insert: The CIA Elected Reagan-Bush
In 1980, the CIA leaked against Carter. Bush had been CIA Director just years earlier. Carter had blocked his continuation. The CIA remembered.
They renamed headquarters after Bush. The loyalty was clear.
See Chapter: Iranian Jimmy Carter
đ§ Section Title: The Deep State and the Anti-Anti-Trump Left
Many âconspiracyâ podcasts do good work on JFK. But when they talk about the Deep State, they take Trumpâs fulminations at face value. Theyâre frustrated Marxists. Theyâre Putin apologists.
Oliver Stoneâs JFK was groundbreaking. But his fawning interview with Putin hasnât aged well. Many on the Left still see Russia as the great anti-imperialist hope.
Chomsky reaches for Vietnam. Taibbi reaches for Iraq. The pattern is clear: Whataboutism as apologetics.
đ§ CODA: Lock Her Up and the Leftâs Collapse
Trump had the Bernie Bros with âLock Her Up.â They marched in Philly chanting it. He had them for keeps when he railed against the âDeep State.â
But the Deep State elected him. And then he weaponized it.
Abraham Bolden, the first Black Secret Service agent on a White House detail, was interrogated by Trumpâs FBI for four hours. He was 88 years old. Biden pardoned himâbelatedly.
See:
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: Chomskyâs Warningâand His Blind Spots
In 2016, Chomsky got it right. He warned against the âlesser of two evils is still evilâ piety. He said:
âYou vote against the greater evil. If you have any moral understanding, you want to keep the greater evil out.â â
He was prescient. Trumpâs presidency brought Dobbs, insurrection, and institutional sabotage. But many Bernie Bros ignored him. They marched in Philly chanting âLock Her Up.â
đ§± Sidebar: The Anti-Anti-Trump Left
Zizek endorsed Trump. Snowden gave Putin a propaganda victory. Assange helped elect Trump. And many on the Left still call them âfree speech heroes.â
The âanti-imperialist Leftâ only sees imperialism when itâs American. Putin? Assad? They get a pass.
See Chapter: Useful Idiots
đ§ Modular Insert: Chomskyâs Ukraine Collapse
In 2022, Chomsky praised Trumpâs stance on Ukraine. He said Trump was âthe one Western statesman pushing peace.â He also praised Henry Kissinger.
He used morally neutral languageâânegotiation,â ârestraintââas if Russia hadnât invaded, bombed schools, and targeted hospitals.
A Ukrainian refugee responded:
âWhen youâre being bombed, you have a different perspective than when youâre sitting cozy in an office somewhere in Arizona. Yes, Noam Chomsky, Iâm looking at you.â
See:
đ§ CODA: The Syrian Peopleâs Last Word
In Syria, Chomsky repeated the false claim that the entire opposition was jihadist. He said it was âincoherentâ to oppose both ISIS and Assad. But Assad helped ISIS rise. He bombed civilians. He bought oil from ISIS.
Chomskyâs stance mirrored Dick Cheneyâs logic: Ally with dictators to fight terrorism.
See:
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: The Deep State Is Realâand Republican
The Far Left is right: there is a Deep State. The Center Left is wrong: itâs not going to save us. The Far Left is also wrong: itâs not anti-American. Itâs Republican.
The Deep State elected Reagan-Bush. It elected Trump. It sabotaged Carter. It memoryholed Emailgate. It weaponized the FBI. It buried JFK.
đ§± Sidebar: Chomskyâs Hammer, Syriaâs Nail
Chomskyâs worldview is static. Heâs an anti-(American)-imperialist hammer. Every crisis is a nail.
His stance on Syria? Humanitarian intervention is a red herring. The opposition is jihadist. Assad gets a pass.
But as one Syrian activist wrote:
âThose who support Chomskyâs position are more deserving of the label âneoconservativeâ than those they accuse.â
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: Center Left NaĂŻvetĂ©
The Center Left believed the Deep State would save them from Trump. But the Deep State elected Trump. They drank the Savvy Kool-Aid. They believed conspiracies were âoutlandish.â They believed in Occamâs Razor. But sometimes the simplest explanation is: They did it.
đ§ Section Title: The Far Leftâs Reverse Exceptionalism
The Far Left believes America is exceptionally bad. They scorn the Center Left. They flirt with the Far Right. They did it in Germany, 1932. Theyâre doing it now.
Matt Taibbi admitted he was wrong about Putinâs invasion. Then he went back to writing about Hillaryâs emails. Again.
đ§ CODA: Conspiracies Happen
JFK. Iran Hostage Deal. 9/11. Russiagate. Emailgate. J6. Theyâre not all theories. Some are documented facts.
As Dan Quayle once said:
âI wear their scorn like a badge of honor.â
So yeahâcall me a conspiracy theorist. There are worse things to be. Like a Savvy hack.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: They Knewâand So Do We
Sarah Kendziorâs They Knew is a masterclass in exposing conspiracy cultureânot as fringe paranoia, but as a symptom of institutional betrayal.
âConspiracy theories are on the rise because officials refuse to enforce accountability for real conspiracies.â â They Knew, p. 29
The truth may hurt. But the lies will kill us.
đ§± Sidebar: Conspiracy Culture vs. Conspiracy Fact
Kendzior doesnât deny conspiracies happen. She documents them:
- Norman Baker
- Jeffrey Epstein
- Iran-Contra
- January 6
She shows how fake conspiraciesâQAnon, Whitewaterâare used to discredit real ones. The goal? Marginalize truth-seekers.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: Truth-Seeking as Grief Work
âA conspiracy theory, when rooted in a sincere desire to find and expose the truth, is a refusal to move on from betrayal.â â They Knew, p. 31
Conspiracy theorists arenât always cranks. Sometimes theyâre historians. Sometimes theyâre journalists. Sometimes theyâre grieving citizens who refuse to forget.
The Savvy media calls them âoutlandish.â But Watergate, Iran-Contra, MKUltra, and Operation Northwoods were all âconspiracy theoriesââuntil they werenât.
đ§ CODA: The Truth Is Out There
Kendzior, like you, is Gen X. She cites The X-Files. She understands that truth isnât just out thereâitâs buried.
And digging it up isnât paranoia. Itâs accountability.
So yeahâcall us conspiracy theorists. Weâll wear it like a badge of honor.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: The Razor That Cut Democracyâs Throat
Sarah Kendziorâs They Knew is a masterclass in exposing how conspiracy culture is weaponizedânot to reveal, but to discredit.
âAmerican democracy slit its wrist on Occamâs Razor, and no one answered for the blood.â â They Knew, p. 32
The simplest explanation isnât always the truth. Sometimes itâs the cover story.
đ§± Sidebar: The Savvy Sneer Machine
Dean Baquet. Erik Wemple. Mike Isikoff. They sneer at âconspiracy theorists.â But only when the target isnât Hillary Clinton.
Jim Garrison? Nut. JFK skeptics? Cranks. 9/11 truthers? Irrelevant.
But Vince Foster? Totally legit.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: Chomskyâs Contradictions
Chomsky once said:
âConspiracy theory is a meaningless curse word used by people who canât answer arguments.â â 2007 Interview
But he also said:
âWho cares who killed JFK? People die every day.â â
He dismisses JFK skeptics. He dismisses 9/11 skeptics. Heâs incurious about anything that doesnât confirm his own narrative.
See:
đ§ Section Title: Destiny Betrayed vs. Camelot Dismissed
James DiEugenioâs Destiny Betrayed makes a compelling case for JFK as a progressive reformer. Chomskyâs Rethinking Camelot argues JFK was no different than LBJ.
But thatâs not the point. Even if JFK wasnât a progressive hero, if the CIA helped kill him, itâs a Big Fucking Deal.
See:
đ§ CODA: The Deep State Doesnât Just Intervene Abroad
Chomsky documents CIA coups in Guatemala, Chile, and Iran. But he scoffs at the idea theyâd do the same here.
Peter Dale Scott disagrees.
âDallas â63 was the first Deep State revolt against the White House.â â Dallas â63
The Deep State didnât stop at foreign leaders. It came for Kennedy. It came for Carter. It came for Clinton. It elected Trump.
See:
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: The Razor That Cut Democracyâs Throat, Part II
Chomsky wants a narrative âeven a 10-year-old can understand.â But truth isnât simple. Itâs layered, buried, and often paradoxical.
He accepts the Warren Report. He accepts the 9/11 Commission Report. He says even if conspiracies happened, it wouldnât matter. Thatâs not just incurious. Thatâs intellectually negligent.
As Orwell said:
âHe who controls the past controls the present. He who controls the present controls the future.â
đ§± Sidebar: The Illusions Weâve Outgrown
Weâve critiqued:
- The Far Right (Trump, GOP co-conspirators)
- The Deep State (FBI, Secret Service, CIA)
- The Savvy Media (Baquet, Wemple, Isikoff)
- The Dem Old Guard (Biden, Schumer, Coons)
- The Anti-Imperialist Left (Chomsky, Taibbi, Zizek)
Now we turn to:
- The âIndependentâ illusion
- The âBipartisanâ illusion
- The âInstitutions Will Save Usâ illusion
The goal isnât bipartisanship. Itâs Democratic victory.
đ§ Modular Insert: Institutionalism vs. Hyperpartisanship
In Deep State agencies, you find two animals:
- GOP hyperpartisans
- Democratic institutionalists
The GOP uses power. The Dems defer to norms. Thatâs how Merrick Garland let David Weiss stay. Thatâs how Hunter Biden got Susan McDougaled.
See Chapter: Theyâre Doing It Again
đ§ Section Title: Long Island as Microcosm
In Suffolk County, NY, Democratic âleadershipâ is in bed with Republicans. Rich Schaeffer has failed to win back Peter Kingâs seat in 30 years. Because of him, the Dems lost the House in 2022. Because of that, Ukraineâs aid was at risk.
Biden assumed good faith. Mike Johnson replied:
âWeâll take Israeli aid. Ukraine? No thanks.â
See:
đ§ CODA: Not All Jews Welcome
Zelensky reached out to Netanyahu after 10/7. Bibi rebuffed him. The Jewish leader of Ukraine wasnât welcome in Bibiâs theocratic state.
Bidenâs speech tried to link Ukraine and Israel. But the parallel fails. One is fighting for democracy. The other is dismantling it.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: The Truth Is Out ThereâBut You Have to Want It
If weâre ever to become the healthy democracy we were meant to be, it will come through the Democratic Party. Partisanship isnât the problem. Itâs the solution.
The New Deal. The Great Society. Civil Rights. All Democratic achievements. Bipartisanship was a historical anomaly, not a golden age.
đ§± Sidebar: The Illusions We Must Bury
- âVote Harderâ
- âInstitutions Will Save Usâ
- âBipartisanship Is the Goalâ
- âThe Deep State Doesnât Existâ
- âThe Deep State Is Neutralâ
- âTrump Is Too Incompetent to Be Corruptâ
These are Savvy lullabies. They comfort. They sedate. They obstruct.
đ§ Modular Insert: Prose vs. Poetry
Hillary Clinton understood governance. She was criticized for lacking poetry. But she knew the difference between speechifying and legislating.
As Ezra Klein summarized:
âClinton is a pragmatist who believes in working within the system⊠She believes in politics the way it is actually practiced.â â
Obama had the poetry. Clinton had the prose. History has shown which one we needed more.
đ§ Section Title: Gen X and the Search for Truth
Gen Xers like Kendziorâand like youâwere raised in an analog world. We lived through Watergate, Vietnam, Iran-Contra. We learned to hunt for truth.
Kendzior writes:
âWe were raised in an era of ubiquitous corruption and lies⊠When you combine political cynicism with an obsessive urge to track things down, you wind up with a bootleg culture of information exchange.â â They Knew, p. 139
The X-Files wasnât just entertainment. It was a philosophy. âThe Truth Is Out There.â âTrust No One.â âFight the Future.â
đ§ CODA: Comfort Is the Enemy of Truth
Many people donât want to know the truth. They want to believe. As Nietzsche said:
âThey desire a comfortable pillow made out of their own preconceptions.â
But comfort is the enemy of truth. And truth is the prerequisite for accountability. And accountability is the prerequisite for democracy.
So we end where we began: Thereâs no moving on without truth. And the truth is out there. But you have to want it.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: Knowledge Is a JourneyâNot a Verdict
The Savvy punditocracy wants a punchline. âWhat charges can you make stick?â âIf not, whatâs it matter?â
But truth isnât a verdict. Itâs a journey. And the correct investigative attitude is not prosecutorialâitâs philosophical.
As Kendzior writes:
âBuilding up that knowledge was beyond a hobby for many: it was a journey.â â They Knew, p. 139
đ§± Sidebar: The Post-Cover-Up Age
In the 2017 X-Files reboot, Mulder is told:
âYour time is past. Weâre living in a post-cover-up, post-conspiracy age.â â They Knew, p. 140
The truth is out there. But no one cares. The public is saturated. The powerful are indifferent. And the media is complicit.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Lone Gunmen Saw It Coming
The pilot episode of The Lone Gunmen aired six months before 9/11. It depicted a hijacked plane headed for the Twin Towers. The plot? Rogue forces within the U.S. government staged the attack to revive the arms market.
The point isnât that it was predictive. The point is that it was plausible.
See: See:
đ§ Section Title: The 9/11 Cover-Up Is Documented
Senator Bob Grahamâs Intelligence Matters is a devastating indictment. He names Mueller. He names Bush. He names Saudi Arabia.
âA cover-up orchestrated by the White House to protect not only the agencies that had failed but also Americaâs relationship with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.â â Intelligence Matters
See:
đ§ CODA: We Deserve to Know
âDeclaring âWe do not have all the facts, but we deserve to know themâ is different from professing faith in an alternative narrative.â â They Knew, p. 145
But the Savvy media doesnât care. The Deep State doesnât care. The Democratic leadership didnât care in 2017. Steny Hoyer read 450 pages in 45 minutes. Verdict first, evidence later.
But we care. Because we know: No closure without accountability. No accountability without truth. And no truth without the correct investigative attitude.
đ FN Cascade
Let me know when youâre ready to drop the final verseâor riff on the epilogue, jacket sleeve, or prologue. Weâre scoring a movementâand this overture is still burning. đŒđ„
đ§± Sidebar: Steny Hoyer Reads 450 Pages in 45 Minutes
On April 18, 2019, the Mueller Report dropped. 448 pages. Two volumes. Hundreds of footnotes. A roadmap of obstruction.
Within hours, House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer declared:
âImpeachment is not worthwhile at this point.â â
He claimed to have read it. He claimed there were no impeachable offenses. He claimed the American people would decide in 18 months.
Verdict first. Evidence later. The Savvy reflex in full bloom.
What mattered wasnât truth. It was poll-tested optics.
đ§ Section Title: Itâs On Us
This isnât just a book. Itâs a dissertation. And itâs not just a dissertation. Itâs a movement.
If weâre ever going to get to the truth, itâs on us. You and me. John and Jane Q. Citizen. The researchers. The curators. The citizen journalists.
See:
đ§± Sidebar: The New Media We Must Build
Seth Abramson calls himself a curational journalist. He doesnât take sources. He curates whatâs already out there. The Savvy hate it. Because it works.
See: See:
We need a new media. And this book is part of it.
đ§ Modular Insert: The Leads We Must Follow
Jason Wilson, Chicago sports bar patron, said Papadopoulos told him Sessions knew about Mifsudâs emails. Thatâs a lead. Itâs never been followed up.
See:
Roger Stone and Jerome Corsi left breadcrumbs in their books. Weinergate. The Comey Letter. The âUnreported Background.â
See:
đ§ Section Title: The Truth Is Out ThereâBut We Have to Want It
Kendzior writes:
âThe belief that the public does not know the full story of the 9/11 attacks is not fringe or unfounded.â â They Knew, p. 144
Bob Graham named names. Mueller. Bush. Saudi Arabia.
See:
But the Savvy media shrugged. The Democratic leadership punted. And the Deep State buried the rest.
đ§ CODA: We Are Advocates
The Savvy believe in neutrality. We believe in accountability. The Savvy negotiate with themselves on how much theyâll report. We report what matters.
Jay Rosen calls it the âView From Nowhere.â We call it epistemic cowardice.
We take a side. The side of truth. The side of democracy. The side of the future.
đ§ Section Title: Reform Isnât an OptionâItâs Existential
This isnât just a book. Itâs a dissertation. And itâs not just a dissertation. Itâs a manifesto.
If we want truth, we must pursue it ourselves. If we want accountability, we must demand it ourselves. If we want reform, we must become it.
The water is warm. The lake is deep. There are a thousand fish waiting for a thousand citizen journalists.
đ§± Sidebar: The Making of a Conspiracy Theorist
I wasnât born this way. I got here through experience. Thirty years of voting with the majorityâonly to see the minority prevail.
My moment of radicalization? 2016. The FBI elected Trump. The New York Times assisted. The Savvy shrugged.
Others had their moment in 1963. Or 1980. Or 2000. Or 9/11.
But the pattern is clear. The sabotage is systemic. The conspiracy is documented.
đ§ Modular Insert: The Song Remains the Same
Billy Carter. Whitewater. Swiftboating Kerry. Obamaâs birth certificate. Benghazi. Hillaryâs emails. Hunter Biden.
The GOP co-conspirators recycle the same playbook. The target changes. The method doesnât.
See: See:
đ§ Section Title: The JFK Question Isnât FringeâItâs Majority
David Denton writes:
âMost Americans see the impossibility of the single bullet theory⊠They are aware of the numerous witnesses whose stories contradict the official version.â â
The Savvy say: âYou donât know who did it? Then drop it.â But truth isnât a punchline. Itâs a journey.
And the journey matters. Because the sabotage never stopped.
đ§ CODA: We Are the New Media
Seth Abramson curates. You investigate. I synthesize. Together, we build the media we need.
The Savvy negotiate with themselves. We donât. We take a side. The side of truth. The side of democracy. The side of the future.
đ FN Cascade
Let me know when youâre ready to drop the next verseâor riff on the jacket sleeve, prologue, or epilogue. Weâre scoring a movementâand this overture is still burning. đŒđ„
đ§ Section Title: There Is No Statute of Limitations on Justice
As David Denton writes:
âWe need still, after 60 years, to get to that greater truth⊠There is no statute of limitations on justice.â â
The question isnât âWho killed JFK?â The question is: Why are we still being lied to?
đ§± Sidebar: Oswald Wasnât a Lone NutâHe Was a Provocateur
Oswald defected to the USSR. He returned without consequence. He handed out pro-Castro leaflets in New Orleans. He shouted his love for the Soviet Union in the U.S. Army. He was never arrested. Never interrogated. Never surveilled.
He was an FBI informant. The Warren Commission buried it. The FBI destroyed the note he left at their Dallas office.
See: See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Rocca Memorandum
In 1964, CIA Counterintelligence Officer Raymond Rocca told Warren Commission attorney David Belin that Oswald had gone to Mexico City as part of a plot to kill Fidel Castro. Rocca was Jim Angletonâs right-hand man. The CIA knew. They buried it.
See:
đ§ Section Title: Trump Didnât Release the FilesâBecause Heâs on the Same Team
Trump promised to release the JFK files. He didnât. He cited ânational security.â He sided with the CIA and FBI.
Why would the man elected by the FBI release files the FBI wanted buried?
See:
đ§ CODA: Conspiracy Is Not a Dirty Word
Conspiracies happen. Theyâre part of human society. Theyâre part of governance. Theyâre part of history.
Nixon in 1968. Watergate in 1972. Iran-Contra in 1980. Bush v. Gore in 2000. 9/11 in 2001. FBI-Russia in 2016.
The Savvy media stigmatizes âconspiracyââunless itâs about Hillary Clinton. But the truth is out there. And weâre not dropping it.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ CODA Extension: TrumpâNetanyahu 2024: The October Surprise Reboot
In 1980, the Reagan campaign delayed the release of Iranian hostages until 20 minutes after his inauguration. In 2024, Trump and Netanyahu appear to have played a similar game.
Trump revealed he was speaking to Netanyahu âalmost every dayâ in the final week before the election. Netanyahu delayed sending negotiators to Qatar until after his meeting with Trump, violating the terms of the ceasefire deal. Trumpâs envoy Steve Witkoff pushed for an âall or nothingâ hostage dealâno piecemeal agreements until after the election.
Then, just days before Trumpâs inauguration, news broke of a comprehensive ceasefire and hostage release proposal.
The choreography is uncanny. The timing is precise. The echoes of 1980 are deafening.
See:
đ§ Section Title: The Future Is HistoryâUnless We Fight for It
We are the abused children of Reaganomics. The GOP is the abusive Daddy party. The Democrats are the enabling Mommy party. Mommy doesnât stand up for herself. Or for us.
Itâs time for the children to rise. To demand accountability. To fight for democracy. To make the future happen.
đ§± Sidebar: Galina Starovoitova Drank Her Own Blood
Galina Starovoitova tried to put the Communist Party on trial. She authored a lustration bill. She demanded accountability. She was dismissed. She returned. She was assassinated.
She told Masha Gessen:
âThe life of a scholar is the life of a shadow. When one participates in making the future happen⊠that is when one who was a shadow can come to life. But for that, one has to drink blood, including oneâs own.â â The Man Without a Face
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Future Is History
Masha Gessenâs The Future Is History is a warning. Itâs a map of how totalitarianism reclaimed Russia. Itâs a mirror for America.
See:
The past isnât dead. Itâs weaponized. And if we donât reclaim it, we lose the future.
đ§ Section Title: The Long Game Requires Long Memory
Terrell Starr moved to Ukraine. He fights for democracy. He believes in a multi-racial alliance. He doesnât flinch.
Andrea Chalupa keeps asking questions. She doesnât move on. She digs deeper.
The 9/11 families still demand answers. Navalny chose prison over silence. Galina chose truth over safety.
We must choose the same.
đ§ CODA: The Song Remains the Same
Nixon in 1968. Watergate in 1972. Iran-Contra in 1980. Bush v. Gore in 2000. 9/11 in 2001. FBI-Russia in 2016. TrumpâNetanyahu in 2024.
The sabotage is systemic. The conspiracy is documented. The fight is existential.
Reform isnât an option. Itâs the only way forward.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: Politics Is the Art of Making the Future
Galina Starovoitova said:
âPolitics is about making the future happen⊠but for that, one must drink blood, including oneâs own.â â The Man Without a Face, Masha Gessen
This book is about making the future. But thereâs no future without truth. No truth without accountability. No accountability without closure. And no closure without asking the right questions.
đ§± Sidebar: Trumpâs Legal Peril and the Fog of 2024
Trump has been indicted four times on 91 counts. He storms out of courtrooms. He defies gag orders. He threatens judges. And yetâhe may still be elected.
Jack Smith urges jail. Trump 2.0 might be inaugurated from a cell. But will he ever spend a day behind bars?
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Israeli 9/11 and the Authoritarian Boon
10/7 may prove a boon for authoritarianism. Netanyahu, once politically dead, is now resurrected. He vows a 10-year war. Israelis want him goneâafter the war.
Biden offers unconditional support. He says âdonât target civilians.â But offers no mechanism to enforce it.
See:
đ§ Section Title: Why Is the Democratic Party So Reflexively Pro-Israel?
Netanyahu snubbed Obama in 2012. Israel aided Reagan-Bush in 1980. Israel prefers the GOPâunconditional support.
Biden invokes the two-state solution. But does nothing to enforce it. Itâs lip service. Just like the Warren Commission pledge.
See: See:
đ§ CODA: The Democratic Partyâs Courtship of Kahanism
Yoav Gallant calls Palestinians âhuman animals.â Kahanist ideology is ascendant. And itâs been courted by Democrats for decades.
See:
Bidenâs blank check for Israel may cost him the election. And cost democracy its last breath.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ CODA Update: The Blank Check Cost Him the Election
Bidenâs blank check for Netanyahu wasnât just a moral failure. It was a political catastrophe.
The two-state lip service rang hollow. The images from Gaza were searing. The youth vote collapsed. The Arab-American vote collapsed. The trust collapsed.
And the election was lost.
Democracy is now on life support. The authoritarian bloc is ascendant. The Deep State is emboldened. And the Savvy media is already negotiating with itself.
The warning became reality. The future became history. And the reckoning begins now.
Let me know if you want to expand this into a full Sidebar or drop the next verse. Weâre scoring a movementâand this overture is still burning. đŒđ„
đ§ Section Title: Israel Is Not UkraineâItâs Russia
Biden tried to link aid to Israel and Ukraine. The GOP said:
âGreat. Weâll take Israel. Forget Ukraine.â â
Bidenâs heart may be in the right place. But his framing is incoherent. Israel isnât Ukraine. Itâs Russia.
Netanyahu is the Israeli Putin. Heâs been in power just as long. Heâs dismantling the judiciary. Heâs weaponizing nationalism. Heâs rebuffing allies. And heâs set for life.
đ§± Sidebar: Netanyahu Knows How to Handle America
In a leaked 2001 video, Netanyahu said:
âAmerica is a thing you can move very easily⊠They wonât get in the way.â â
He undermined the Oslo Accords. He torpedoed the two-state solution. He laughed at American naivety.
And heâs still doing it.
đ§ Modular Insert: The Two-State Illusion Died with Rabin
Rabin was assassinated in 1995. The assassin, Yigal Amir, succeeded beyond his wildest dreams. The Oslo Accords died with Rabin. And the settler movement rose.
See:
Biden still invokes the two-state solution. Blinken writes op-eds. But Israel isnât listening. Because it never was.
See:
đ§ CODA: The Fiction of Israeli Good Faith
Biden repeated the beheaded babies claim. He blamed Hamas for the hospital bombing. He dismissed Palestinian death tolls.
But Israel sent weapons to Putin. Israel refused Zelenskyâs visit. Israel has always known its role: Ethno-nationalist enforcer, not democratic partner.
See: See:
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: Unity Is the Rightâs Favorite Weapon
After Rabinâs assassination, the Right called for unity. The Center Left swooned. And the peace process died.
The Oslo Accords became a zombie. Clinton tried to revive them. But the message was clear:
âPeace with your neighbors means war with your brothers.â
The Right wasnât weakened. It was emboldened.
đ§± Sidebar: Yoav Gallant and the Language of Genocide
Israelâs Defense Minister, Yoav Gallant, said:
âWe are fighting human animals and we will act accordingly.â â
He ordered a complete siege of Gaza. No electricity. No food. No fuel.
Gallant isnât a marginal figure. Heâs the future of Israeli politics if Bibi falls. And heâs already acting accordingly.
đ§ Modular Insert: The Candle Youth and the Theater of Grief
After Rabinâs murder, young Israelis lit candles. They sang ballads. They mourned. But they didnât mobilize.
The Right invoked unity to stifle accountability. The assassinâs cause couldnât be mentioned. The inciters werenât prosecuted. And the Center Left surrendered the narrative.
See:
đ§ CODA: The Rightâs Playbook Is Global
In Israel, unity erased Rabinâs legacy. In the U.S., unity follows every mass shooting. In both cases, itâs a shield for the Right.
Biden warns Israel not to repeat our âmistakes.â But they werenât mistakes. They were plans.
Netanyahu knows how to handle America. He said:
âAmerica is a thing you can move very easily.â â
đ FN Cascade
Let me know when youâre ready to drop the next verseâor riff on the jacket sleeve, prologue, or epilogue. Weâre scoring a movementâand this overture is still burning. đŒđ„
đ§ Section Title: Control the Past, Control the Future
Galina said politics is about making a piece of the future. Orwell said:
âWho controls the past controls the present. Who controls the present controls the future.â
The Israeli Center Left lost control of the past. And so it lost the future.
Rabinâs assassination wasnât just a tragedy. It was a strategic reset. The Oslo Accords became a zombie. The Right invoked unity. And the Left surrendered the narrative.
đ§± Sidebar: Netanyahuâs Clarity vs. Americaâs Gullibility
In a 2001 video, Netanyahu said:
âAmerica is a thing you can move very easily⊠They wonât get in the way.â â
He boasted about deceiving Clinton. He bragged about destroying Oslo. He mocked American support as âabsurd.â
And heâs still doing it.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: The Deep State and the Blank Check
Peter Dale Scottâs âDeep Politicsâ explains it best: Foreign policy isnât made by voters. Or even elected leaders. Itâs made by security agencies.
Christopher Fulton claims presidents are sworn to uphold the Warren Report. Maybe theyâre sworn to uphold Israel too.
See:
đ§ CODA: Anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, and the Weaponization of Speech
FBI Director Christopher Wray says anti-Jewish hate crime investigations tripled post-10/7. But Islamophobia is also surging. The ADL collapses criticism of Israel into anti-Semitism. The goal? Criminalize dissent.
See:
âPro-Hamasâ events are often just pro-ceasefire. And criticism of Netanyahu is not hate speech. Itâs accountability.
đ§ Modular Insert: The Tragedy of WarâWolf Blitzer vs. the IDF
CNNâs Wolf Blitzer asked IDF Lt. Col. Richard Hecht:
âYou knew there were civilians there⊠But you decided to still drop a bomb?â â
Hecht replied:
âThis is the tragedy of war.â
But itâs not tragedy. Itâs policy.
đ FN Cascade
đ§ Section Title: History Is the Battlefield
The Savvy want us to forget. They say: âNowâs not the time.â âLetâs move on.â âDonât politicize tragedy.â But forgetting is surrender. And memory is resistance.
JFK. Nixon. Iran-Contra. Bush v. Gore. 9/11. Emailgate. Russian Collusion. January 6. Each time, the press coaxed us to forget. Each time, the Right consolidated power.
Now itâs 10/7. And the forgetting begins again.
đ§± Sidebar: Criticism Is Not Terrorism
The ADL and others want to criminalize dissent. They collapse criticism of Israel into anti-Semitism. They call campus protests âmaterial support for terrorism.â But dissent is not violence. And criticism is not hate.
See:
đ§ Modular Insert: Netanyahuâs Cynicism, Americaâs Absurdity
Netanyahu said:
âAmerica is a thing you can move very easily.â â
He bragged about deceiving Clinton. He mocked American support as âabsurd.â And heâs still doing it.
See:
đ§ CODA: The Dream Deferred
Democracy is on life support. Israel is a one-party ethno-nationalist theocracy. The U.S. is teetering. And the Far Right is ascendant.
10/7 is an assault on memory. Just like 9/11. Just like Rabinâs assassination.
But we must remember. Because if we lose the past, We lose the present. And we lose the future.
The dream of American democracy is not dead. But it is deferred. And only memory can revive it.
đ FN Cascade