Section 3: Genetics and Prenatal Development
3.1 Genetics and Heredity
How do genes influence development?
- Define gene, chromosome, and gamete.
- Distinguish between mitosis and meiosis, genotype and phenotype, homozygous and heterozygous, and dominant and recessive.
- Question the assertion that human traits are genetic. Define genotype-environment correlations and genotype-environment interactions, and define epigenetics.
- Differentiate between genetic disorders and chromosomal abnormalities. Describe Trisomy 21.
- Describe the function of genetic counseling.
- Explore how genetics and environment correlate.
- Compare monozygotic and dizygotic twins
Before we discuss the birth process and some of the complications that can occur during delivery, it is important to understand how genes and chromosomes affect development.
Nature refers to the contribution of genetics to one’s development. The basic building block of the nature perspective is the gene. Genes are recipes for making proteins, which influence the structure and functions of cells. Genes are located on the chromosomes, and according to the Human Genome Project (National Institute of Health, 2015), there are an estimated 20,500 genes in humans. See the box below for more details on the Human Genome Project.
Heredity and Chromosomes
Gametes
There are two types of sex cells or gametes involved in reproduction: the male gametes, or sperm, and female gametes, or ova. The male gametes are produced in the testes through a process called spermatogenesis, which begins at about 12 years of age. The female gametes, which are stored in the ovaries, are present at birth but are immature. Each ovary contains about 250,000 ova but only about 400 of these will become mature eggs (Mackon & Fauser, 2000; Rome, 1998). Beginning at puberty, one ovum ripens and is released about every 28 days, a process called oogenesis.
After the ovum or egg ripens and is released from the ovary, it is drawn into the fallopian tube and, in 3 to 4 days, reaches the uterus. It is typically fertilized in the fallopian tube and continues its journey to the uterus. At ejaculation, millions of sperm are released into the vagina, but only a few reach the egg, and typically, only one fertilizes the egg. Once a single sperm has entered the wall of the egg, the wall becomes hard and prevents other sperm from entering. After the sperm has entered the egg, the tail of the sperm breaks off, and the head of the sperm, containing the genetic information from the father, unites with the nucleus of the egg. As a result, a new cell is formed. This cell, containing the combined genetic information from both parents, is referred to as a zygote.
Chromosomes
While other normal human cells have 46 chromosomes (or 23 pairs), gametes contain 23 chromosomes. Chromosomes are long threadlike structures found in a cell nucleus that contain genetic material known as deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). DNA is a helix-shaped molecule made up of nucleotide base pairs [adenine (A), guanine (G), cytosine (C), and thymine (T)]. In each chromosome, sequences of DNA make up genes that control or partially control a number of visible characteristics, known as traits, such as eye color, hair color, and so on. A single gene may have multiple possible variations or alleles. An allele is a specific version of a gene. So, a given gene may code for the trait of hair color, and the different alleles of that gene affect which hair color an individual has.
Normal human cells contain 46 chromosomes (or 23 pairs, one from each parent) in the nucleus of the cells. After conception, most cells of the body are created by a process called mitosis.
In meiosis, the gamete’s chromosomes duplicate and then divide twice, resulting in four cells containing only half the genetic material of the original gamete. Thus, each sperm and egg possesses 23 chromosomes and combine to produce what is considered to be normative—a total of 46. See Figure 3 for details on both mitosis and meiosis. Given the number of genes present and the unpredictability of the meiosis process, the likelihood of having offspring that are genetically identical (and not twins) is one in trillions (Gould, J. L., & Keeton, W. T., 1997).
Genotypes and Phenotypes
The word genotype refers to the sum total of all the genes a person inherits.
The word phenotype refers to the features that are actually expressed.
When a sperm and egg fuse, their 23 chromosomes pair up and create a zygote with 23 pairs of chromosomes. Therefore, each parent contributes half the genetic information carried by the offspring; the resulting physical characteristics of the offspring (called the phenotype) are determined by the interaction of genetic material supplied by the parents (called the genotype). A person’s genotype is the genetic makeup of that individual. Phenotype, on the other hand, refers to the individual’s inherited and observable physical and psychological characteristics, like their hair color or personality
Look in the mirror. What do you see, your genotype or your phenotype? What determines whether or not genes are expressed?
Actually, this is quite complicated. Some features follow the additive pattern, which means that many different genes contribute to a final outcome. Height and skin tone are examples. In other cases, a gene might either be turned on or off depending on several factors, including the gene with which it is paired or the inherited epigenetic tags.
Link to Learning
Visit the webpage “What are DNA and Genes?” from the University of Utah to better understand DNA and genes, then watch the video “What is Inheritance?” to learn how the genes from parents pass on genetic information to their children.
The Human Genome Project
In 1990, the Human Genome Project (HGP), an international scientific endeavor, began the task of sequencing the 3 billion base pairs that make up the human genome. In April of 2003, more than two years ahead of schedule, scientists gave us the genetic blueprint for building a human. Since this time, using the information from the HGP, researchers have discovered the genes involved in over 1800 diseases. In 2005, the HGP amassed a large database called HapMap that catalogs the genetic variations in 11 global populations. Data on genetic variation can improve our understanding of differential risk for disease and reactions to medical treatments, such as drugs. Pharmacogenomic researchers have already developed tests to determine whether a patient will respond favorably to certain drugs used in the treatment of breast cancer or HIV by using information from HapMap.
Future directions for the HGP include identifying the genetic markers for all 50 major forms of cancer (The Cancer Genome Atlas), continuing to use the HapMap to create more effective drugs for disease treatment, and examining the legal, social, and ethical implications of genetic knowledge.
From the outset, the HGP made ethical issues one of their main concerns. Part of the HGP’s budget supports research and holds workshops that address these concerns. Who owns this information and how the availability of genetic information may influence healthcare and its impact on individuals, their families, and the greater community are just some of the many questions being addressed.
Determining the Sex of the Child
Twenty-two of those chromosomes from each parent are similar in length to a corresponding chromosome from the other parent. However, the remaining chromosome looks like an X or a Y. Half of the male’s sperm contains a Y chromosome, and half contains an X. All of the ova contain X chromosomes. If the child receives the combination of XY, the child will be genetically male. If it receives the XX combination, the child will be genetically female.
Many potential parents have a clear preference for having a boy or a girl and would like to determine the sex of the child. Through the years, a number of tips have been offered for potential parents to maximize their chances of having either a son or daughter as they prefer. However, there is not much scientific evidence to back these claims. Today, however, there is new technology available called sperm sorting that makes it possible to isolate sperm containing either an X or a Y, depending on the preference, and use that sperm to fertilize a mother’s egg. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) could also be used to select only embryos of the desired sex to be implanted during in-vitro fertilization (IVF). However, these methods are controversial, and both fertility centers and medical organizations discourage it if there is no real medical reason to select gender.
Many genetic variations can occur within the sex chromosomes. For instance, people who have Turner syndrome typically have only one sex chromosome, an X, and people with Klinefelter syndrome have an extra X chromosome (XXY). See Table 1 below.
Genetic Variations and Inheritance
Genetic variation, the genetic differences between individuals, is what contributes to a species’ ability to adapt to its environment. In humans, genetic variation begins with an egg, several million sperm, and fertilization. The egg and the sperm each contain 23 chromosomes, which make up our genes. A single gene may have multiple possible variations or alleles (a specific version of a gene), resulting in a variety of combinations of inherited traits.
Because genes are inherited in pairs on the chromosomes, we may receive the same version of a gene from our mother and father, that is, be homozygous for that characteristic the gene influences. If we receive a different version of the gene from each parent, that is referred to as heterozygous. In the homozygous situation, we will display that characteristic. It is in the heterozygous condition that it becomes clear that not all genes are created equal.
Some genes are dominant, meaning they express themselves in the phenotype even when paired with a different version of the gene, while their silent partner is called recessive. Dominant traits include curly hair, facial dimples, normal vision, and dark hair.
Recessive genes express themselves only when paired with a similar version of a gene. Recessive characteristics include red hair, pattern baldness, and nearsightedness.
Most characteristics are not the result of a single gene; they are polygenic, meaning they are the result of several genes. In addition, the dominant and recessive patterns described above are usually not that simple either. Some characteristics that were once thought of as dominant-recessive, such as eye color, are now believed to be a result of the interaction between several genes (McKusick, 1998).
Sometimes, the dominant gene does not completely suppress the recessive gene; this is called incomplete dominance.
An example of this can be found in the recessive gene disorder sickle cell disease. The gene that produces healthy round-shaped red blood cells is dominant. The recessive gene causes an abnormality in the shape of red blood cells; they take on a sickle form, which can clog the veins, deprive vital organs of oxygen, and increase the risk of stroke. To inherit the disorder, a person must receive the recessive gene from both parents. Those who have inherited only one recessive gene are called carriers and should be unaffected by this recessive trait. Yet, carriers of sickle cell have some red blood cells that take on the c-shaped sickle pattern. Under circumstances of oxygen deprivation, such as high altitudes or physical exertion, carriers for the sickle cell gene may experience some of the symptoms of sickle cell (Berk, L. 2004).
Sickle cell anemia is an autosomal recessive disease; Huntington’s disease is an autosomal dominant disease. Other traits are a result of partial dominance or co-dominance in which both genes are influential. For example, if a person inherits both recessive genes for cystic fibrosis, the disease will occur. However, if a person has only one recessive gene for the disease, the person would be a carrier of the disease.
In this example, we will call the normal gene “N,” and the gene for cystic fibrosis “c.” The normal gene is dominant, which means that having the dominant allele either from one parent (Nc) or both parents (NN) will always result in the phenotype associated with the dominant allele. When someone has two copies of the same allele, they are said to be homozygous for that allele. When someone has a combination of alleles for a given gene, they are said to be heterozygous. For example, cystic fibrosis is a recessive disease, which means that an individual will only have the disease if they are homozygous for that recessive allele (cc).
Imagine that a woman who is a carrier of the cystic fibrosis gene has a child with a man who is also a carrier of the same disease. What are the odds that their child would inherit the disease? Both the woman and the man are heterozygous for this gene (Nc). We can expect the offspring to have a 25% chance of having cystic fibrosis (cc), a 50% chance of being a carrier of the disease (Nc), and a 25% chance of receiving two normal copies of the gene (NN).
Where do harmful genes that contribute to diseases like cystic fibrosis come from? Gene mutations are one source of harmful genes. A mutation is a sudden, permanent change in a gene. While many mutations can be harmful or lethal, some mutations are beneficial by giving a person an advantage over those who do not have the mutation. Recall that the theory of evolution maintains that individuals best adapted to their particular environments are more likely to reproduce and pass on their genes to future generations. In order for this process to occur, there must be variability in genes (and resultant traits) that allow for variation in adaptability to the environment. If a population consisted of identical individuals, then any dramatic changes in the environment would affect everyone in the same way, and there would be no variation in selection. In contrast, diversity in genes and associated traits allows some individuals to perform slightly better than others when faced with environmental change. This creates a distinct advantage for individuals best suited for their environments in terms of successful reproduction and genetic transmission.
Link to Learning
Visit the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation to learn more about cystic fibrosis and learn how a mutation in DNA leads to the disease.
Chromosomal Abnormalities and Genetic Testing
Chromosomal Abnormalities
A chromosomal abnormality occurs when a child inherits too many or too few chromosomes. The most common cause of chromosomal abnormalities is the age of the mother. A 20-year-old woman has a 1 in 800 chance of having a child with a common chromosomal abnormality. A woman of 44, however, has a one in 16 chance. It is believed that the problem occurs when the ovum is ripening prior to ovulation each month. As the mother ages, the ovum is more likely to suffer abnormalities at this time.
Another common cause of chromosomal abnormalities occurs because the gametes do not divide evenly when they are forming. Therefore, some cells have more than 46 chromosomes. In fact, it is believed that close to half of all zygotes have an odd number of chromosomes. Most of these zygotes fail to develop and are spontaneously aborted by the body. If the abnormal number occurs on pair # 21 or # 23, however, the individual may have certain physical or other abnormalities.
An altered chromosome structure may take several different forms and result in various disorders or malignancies:
- Deletions: A portion of the chromosome is missing or deleted. Known disorders in humans include Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome, which is caused by partial deletion of the short arm of chromosome 4, and Jacobsen syndrome, also called terminal 11q deletion disorder.
- Duplications: A portion of the chromosome is duplicated, resulting in extra genetic material. Known human disorders include Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A, which may be caused by duplication of the gene encoding peripheral myelin protein 22 (PMP22) on chromosome 17.
- Translocations: A portion of one chromosome is transferred to another chromosome. There are two main types of translocations:
- Reciprocal translocation: Segments from two different chromosomes have been exchanged.
- Robertsonian translocation: An entire chromosome has attached to another at the centromere—in humans, this only occurs with chromosomes 13, 14, 15, 21, and 22.
- Inversions: A portion of the chromosome has broken off, turned upside down, and reattached, therefore the genetic material is inverted.
- Insertions: A portion of one chromosome has been deleted from its normal place and inserted into another chromosome.
- Rings: A portion of a chromosome has broken off and formed a circle or ring. This can happen with or without loss of genetic material.
- Isochromosome: Formed by the mirror image copy of a chromosome segment, including the centromere.
One of the most common chromosomal abnormalities is on pair # 21. Trisomy 21 occurs when there are three rather than two chromosomes on #21. A person with Down syndrome has distinct facial features, intellectual disability, and oftentimes heart and gastrointestinal disorders. Symptoms vary from person to person and can range from mild to severe. With early intervention, the life expectancy of persons with Down syndrome has increased in recent years. Keep in mind that there is as much variation in people with Down Syndrome as in most populations, and those differences need to be recognized and appreciated.
When the chromosomal abnormality is on pair #23, the result is a sex-linked chromosomal abnormality. A person might have XXY, XYY, XXX, XO, or 45 or 47 chromosomes as a result. Two of the more common sex-linked chromosomal disorders are Turner syndrome and Klinefelter syndrome. Turner’s syndrome occurs in 1 of every 2,500 live female births when an ovum that lacks a chromosome is fertilized by a sperm with an X chromosome (Carroll, 2007). The resulting zygote has an XO composition. Fertilization by a Y sperm is not viable. Turner syndrome affects cognitive functioning and sexual maturation. The external genitalia appear normal, but breasts and ovaries do not develop fully, and the woman does not menstruate. Turner’s syndrome also results in short stature and other physical characteristics. Klinefelter syndrome (XXY) occurs in 1 out of 700 live male births and results when an ovum containing an extra X chromosome is fertilized by a Y sperm. The Y chromosome stimulates the growth of male genitalia, but the additional X chromosome inhibits this development. An individual with Klinefelter syndrome has some breast development, infertility (this is the most common cause of infertility in males), and low levels of testosterone.
Genetic Disorders
Most known genetic disorders are dominant gene-linked; however, the vast majority of dominant gene-linked disorders are not serious or debilitating. For example, the majority of those with Tourette’s Syndrome suffer only minor tics from time to time and can easily control their symptoms. Huntington’s Disease is a dominant gene-linked disorder that affects the nervous system and is fatal but does not appear until midlife. Recessive gene disorders, such as cystic fibrosis and sickle-cell anemia, are less common but may actually claim more lives because they are less likely to be detected, so people are unaware that they are carriers of the disease. Some genetic disorders are sex-linked; the defective gene is found on the X chromosome. Males have only one X chromosome, so they are at greater risk for sex-linked disorders due to a recessive gene, such as hemophilia, color blindness, and baldness. For females to be affected by genetic defects, they need to inherit the recessive gene on both X-chromosomes, but if the defective gene is dominant, females can be equally at risk. Table 1 lists several genetic disorders.
Recessive Disorders (Homozygous): The individual inherits a gene change from both parents. If the gene is inherited from just one parent, the person is a carrier and does not have the condition. | Cases per Birth |
Sickle Cell Disease (SCD) is a condition in which the red blood cells in the body are shaped like a sickle (like the letter C) and affect the ability of the blood to transport oxygen. Carriers may experience some effects, but do not have the full condition. | 1 in 500 Black births
1 in 36,000 Hispanic births |
Cystic Fibrosis (CF) is a condition that affects breathing and digestion due to thick mucus building up in the body, especially the lungs and digestive system. In
CF, the mucus is thicker than normal and sticky. |
1 in 3500 |
Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a metabolic disorder in which the individual cannot metabolize phenylalanine, an amino acid. Left untreated intellectual deficits occur. PKU is easily detected and is treated with a special diet. | 1 in 10,000 |
Tay Sachs Disease is caused by enzyme deficiency resulting in the accumulation of lipids in the nerve cells of the brain. This accumulation results in progressive damage to the cells and a decrease in cognitive and physical development. Death typically occurs by age five. | 1 in 4000
1in 30 American Jews is a carrier 1 in 20 French Canadians is a carrier |
Albinism is when the individual lacks melanin and possesses little to no pigment in the skin, hair, and eyes. Vision problems can also occur. | Fewer than 20,000 US cases per year |
Autosomal Dominant Disorders (Heterozygous): In order to have the disorder, the individual only needs to inherit the gene change from one parent. | Cases per Birth |
Huntington’s Disease is a condition that affects the individual’s nervous system. Nerve cells become damaged, causing various parts of the brain to deteriorate. The disease affects movement, behavior and cognition. It is fatal, and occurs at midlife. | 1 in 10,000 |
Tourette Syndrome is a tic disorder which results in uncontrollable motor and vocal tics as well as body jerking. | 1 in 250 |
Achondroplasia is the most common form of disproportionate short stature. The individual has abnormal bone growth resulting in short stature, disproportionately short arms and legs, short fingers, a large head, and specific facial features. | 1 in 15,000-40,000 |
Sex-Linked Disorders: When the X chromosome carries the mutated gene, the disorder is referred to as an X-linked disorder. Males are more affected than females because they possess only one X chromosome without an additional X chromosome to counter the harmful gene. | Cases per Birth |
Fragile X Syndrome occurs when the body cannot make enough of a protein it needs for the brain to grow and problems with learning and behavior can occur. Fragile X syndrome is caused from an abnormality in the X chromosome, which then breaks. If a female has fragile X, her second X chromosome usually is healthy, but males with fragile X don’t have a second healthy X chromosome.
This is why symptoms of fragile X syndrome usually are more serious in males. |
1 in 4000 males
1 in 8000 females |
Hemophilia occurs when there are problems in blood clotting causing both internal and external bleeding. | 1 in 10,000 males |
Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy is a weakening of the muscles resulting in an inability to move, wasting away, and possible death. | 1 in 3500 males |
Watch the following video clip about Down syndrome from the National Down Syndrome Society:
You can view the transcript for “Down syndrome – Ability Awareness PSA Video” here (opens in new window).
Autosomal Chromosome Disorders: The individual inherits too many or two few chromosomes. | Cases per Birth |
Down syndrome/Trisomy 21 is caused by an extra chromosome 21 and includes a combination of birth defects. Affected individuals have some degree of intellectual variations, characteristic facial features, often heart defects, and other health problems. The severity varies greatly among affected individuals. | 1 in 691
1 in 300 births at age 35 |
Trisomy 13 is caused by an extra chromosome 13. Affected individuals have multiple birth defects and generally die in the first weeks or months of life. | 1 in 7,906 |
Trisomy 18 is caused by an extra chromosome 18 and the affected individual also has multiple birth defects within many areas of the body and typically results in early death. | 1 in 3,762 |
Sex-Linked Chromosomal Disorders: The disorder occurs on chromosome pair #23 or the sex chromosomes. | Cases per Birth |
Turner Syndrome is caused when all or part of one of the X chromosomes is lost before or soon after conception due to a random event. The resulting zygote has an XO composition. Turner Syndrome typically affects cognitive functioning and sexual maturation in girls. Infertility and a short stature may be noted. | 1 in 2500 females |
Klinefelter Syndrome is caused when an extra X chromosome is present in the cells of a male due to a random event. The Y chromosome stimulates the growth of male genitalia, but the additional X chromosome inhibits this development. The male may have some breast development, infertility, and low levels of testosterone. | 1 in 700 males |
Genetic Counseling
Genetic counseling refers to a service that assists individuals in identifying, testing for, and explaining potential genetic conditions that could adversely affect themselves or their offspring (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2015). The more common reasons for genetic counseling include:
- Family history of a genetic condition.
- Membership in a certain ethnic group with a higher risk of a genetic condition.
- Information regarding the results of genetic testing, including blood tests, amniocentesis, or ultrasounds.
- Learning about the chances of having a baby with a genetic condition if the mother is older, has had several miscarriages, has offspring with birth defects, experiences infertility, or has a medical condition.
Behavioral Genetics
Behavioral Genetics is the scientific study of the interplay between the genetic and environmental contributions to behavior. Often referred to as the nature/nurture debate, Gottlieb suggests an analytic framework for this debate that recognizes the interplay between the environment, behavior, and genetic expression (Gottlieb, 2002). This bidirectional interplay suggests that the environment can affect the expression of genes just as genetic predispositions can impact a person’s potential. Additionally, environmental circumstances can trigger symptoms of a genetic disorder. For example, a person who has sickle cell anemia, a recessive gene-linked disorder, can experience a sickle cell crisis under conditions of oxygen deprivation. Someone predisposed genetically to type-two diabetes can trigger the disease through poor diet and little exercise.
Research has shown how the environment and genotype interact in several ways. Genotype-environment correlations refer to the processes by which genetic factors contribute to variations in the environment (Plomin, et al., 2013).
There are three types of genotype-environment correlations:
- Passive genotype-environment correlation occurs when children passively inherit the genes and the environments their family provides. Certain behavioral characteristics, such as being athletically inclined, may run in families. The children have inherited both the genes that would enable success at these activities and are given the environmental encouragement to engage in these actions.
- Evocative genotype-environment correlation refers to how the social environment reacts to individuals based on their inherited characteristics. For example, whether one has a more outgoing or shy temperament will affect how they are treated by others.
- Active genotype-environment correlation occurs when individuals seek out environments that support their genetic tendencies. This is also referred to as niche picking. For example, children who are musically inclined seek out music instruction and opportunities that facilitate their natural musical ability.
Conversely, genotype-environment interactions involve genetic susceptibility to the environment. Adoption studies provide evidence for genotype-environment interactions. For example, the Early Growth and Development Study followed 360 adopted children and their adopted and biological parents in a longitudinal study (Leve, et al., 2010). Results revealed that children whose biological parents exhibited psychopathology exhibited significantly fewer behavior problems when their adoptive parents used more structured parenting than unstructured. Additionally, elevated psychopathology in adoptive parents increased the risk for the children’s development of behavior problems, but only when the biological parents’ psychopathology was high. Consequently, the results demonstrate how environmental effects on behavior differ based on the genotype, especially stressful environments on genetically at-risk children.
Scarr’s Three
Genetic and situational contributions to an individual’s makeup are linked, and the combination of influences impacts individuals in three distinct ways. How we are raised affects not only us because of the experience itself but also because those experiences result from the combination of genetic and environmental influences on our parents. Furthermore, our genetic makeup influences both the environmental influences that come to us and those that we particularly seek out. Combining these three processes of confounded influence creates the person we become.
Consider your experience regarding Sandra Scarr’s three ways heredity and environment correlate. Answer the following questions with examples from your life experience.
- Passive: What kind of environmental experiences did your parents provide for you because of who they were?
- Evocative: What environmental experiences did you have due to your genetic makeup?
- Active: What environmental experiences did you seek out due to aspects of your genetic makeup?
Example:
Passive: One example of an environmental experience my parents provided was the educational environment. My mom was an elementary school teacher so I spent a lot of days in the summer at her school while she prepared her classroom for the school year. I also came to her room after school, and my teachers were my mom’s friends. Because of this, I had a lot of experience in a school environment beyond what a student would experience. I even got to eat in the teacher’s lunchroom sometimes when I had to come to work with my mom after Kindergarten.
Evocative: Due to my genetic makeup as having the trait of shyness from what I remember as a kid, there were only certain people that I felt comfortable being around, so my mom would only leave me with family members or godparents.
Active: I sought out the performing arts as an environmental niche. I played multiple instruments from 4th grade, was involved in children’s theater, and went to a performing arts high school. I majored in Drama when I went to DVC but later sought out the education niche modeled by my mom in my early experience. I ended up getting multiple degrees and working in education for my entire career.
Resources
Interesting page on behavioral genetics
Nature or Nurture?
For decades, scholars have carried on the “nature/nurture” debate. For any particular feature, those on the “nature” side would argue that heredity plays the most important role in bringing about that feature. Those on the “nurture” side would argue that one’s environment is most significant in shaping the way we are. This debate continues with questions about what makes us masculine or feminine (Lippa, 2002), concerns about vision (Mutti et al., 1996), and many other developmental issues.
Most scholars agree that there is a constant interplay between the two forces. It is difficult to isolate the root of any single behavior as a result solely of nature or nurture, and most scholars believe that even determining the extent to which nature or nurture impacts a human feature is difficult to answer. In fact, almost all human features are polygenic (a result of many genes) and multifactorial (a result of many factors, both genetic and environmental). It is as if one’s genetic makeup sets up a range of possibilities, which may or may not be realized depending upon one’s environmental experiences. For instance, a person might be genetically predisposed to develop diabetes, but the person’s lifestyle may help bring about the disease.
When you think about your own family history, it is easy to see that there are certain personality traits, behavioral characteristics, and medical conditions that are more common than others. This is the reason that doctors ask you about your family medical history. Environmental factors, such as nutrition, stress, and teratogens, are thought to change gene expression by switching genes on and off.
While genetic predisposition is important to consider, some family members seem to defy the odds of developing these conditions for various reasons. These differences can be explained in part by the effect of epigenetic (above-genome) changes.
The Epigenetic Framework
The term “epigenetic” has been used in developmental psychology to describe psychological development as the result of an ongoing, bi-directional interchange between heredity and the environment. Gottlieb (1998; 2000; 2002) suggests an analytic framework for the nature/nurture debate that recognizes the interplay between the environment, behavior, and genetic expression. This bidirectional interplay suggests that the environment can affect the expression of genes just as genetic predispositions can impact a person’s potential. Likewise, environmental circumstances can trigger symptoms of a genetic disorder. For example, a person predisposed genetically to type 2 diabetes may trigger the disease through poor diet and little exercise.
The developmental psychologist Erik Erikson wrote of an epigenetic principle in his book Identity: Youth and Crisis (1968), encompassing the notion that we develop through an unfolding of our personality in predetermined stages and that our environment and surrounding culture influence how we progress through these stages. This biological unfolding in relation to our socio-cultural settings is done in stages of psychosocial development, where “progress through each stage is in part determined by our success, or lack of success, in all the previous stages.”
In typical human families, children’s biological parents raise them, so it is very difficult to know whether children act like their parents due to genetic (nature) or environmental (nurture) reasons. Nevertheless, despite our restrictions on setting up human-based experiments, we do see real-world examples of nature-nurture at work in the human sphere—though they only provide partial answers to our many questions.
The science of how genes and environments work together to influence behavior is called behavioral genetics. The easiest opportunity we have to observe this is the adoption study. When children are put up for adoption, the parents who give birth to them are no longer the parents who raise them. Children aren’t assigned to random adoptive parents in order to suit the particular interests of a scientist, but adoption still tells us some interesting things or at least confirms some basic expectations. For instance, if the biological child of tall parents were adopted into a family of short people, do you suppose the child’s growth would be affected? What about the biological child of a Spanish-speaking family adopted at birth into an English-speaking family? What language would you expect the child to speak? And what might these outcomes tell you about the difference between height and language in terms of nature-nurture?
Monozygotic and Dizygotic Twins
Another option for observing nature-nurture in humans involves twin studies.
Many students are interested in twins. Monozygotic or identical twins occur when a fertilized egg splits apart in the first two weeks of development (Figure 7). The result is the creation of two separate but genetically identical offspring. That is, they possess the same genotype and often the same phenotype. About one-third of twins are monozygotic twins. Monozygotic twins occur in birthing at a rate of about 3 in every 1000 deliveries worldwide (about 0.3% of the world population). Monozygotic twins are genetically nearly identical and they are always the same sex unless there has been a mutation during development. The children of monozygotic twins test genetically as half-siblings (or full siblings if a pair of monozygotic twins reproduces with another pair of identical twins or with the same person) rather than first cousins.
Sometimes, however, two eggs or ova are released and fertilized by two separate sperm. The result is dizygotic or fraternal twins (Figure 8). These two individuals share the same amount of genetic material as would any two children from the same mother and father. In other words, they possess a different genotype and phenotype. Older mothers are more likely to have dizygotic twins than younger mothers, and couples who use fertility drugs are also more likely to give birth to dizygotic twins. Consequently, there has been an increase in the number of fraternal twins recently (Bortolus, et al., 1999). In vitro fertilization (IVF) techniques are more likely to create dizygotic twins. For IVF deliveries, there are nearly 21 pairs of twins for every 1,000.
In the uterus, a majority of monozygotic twins (60–70%) share the same placenta but have separate amniotic sacs. The placenta is a temporary organ that connects the developing fetus via the umbilical cord to the uterine wall to allow nutrient uptake, thermo-regulation, waste elimination, and gas exchange via the mother’s blood supply. The amniotic sac (also called the bag of waters or the membranes) is a thin but tough transparent pair of membranes that hold a developing embryo (and later fetus) until shortly before birth. In 18–30% of monozygotic twins each fetus has a separate placenta and a separate amniotic sac. A small number (1–2%) of monozygotic twins share the same placenta and amniotic sac. Fraternal twins each have their own placenta and amniotic sac.
Monozygotic (one egg/identical) twins can be categorized into four types depending on the timing of the separation and duplication of cells. Various types of chorionicity and animosity (how the baby’s sac looks) in monozygotic twins result when the fertilized egg divides, a process known as placentation.
Conjoined twins
Conjoined twins are monozygotic twins whose bodies are joined together during pregnancy. This occurs when the zygote starts to split after day 12 following fertilization and fails to separate completely. This condition occurs in about 1 in 50,000 human pregnancies. Most conjoined twins are now evaluated for surgery to attempt to separate them into separate functional bodies. The degree of difficulty rises if a vital organ or structure is shared between twins, such as the brain, heart, or liver.
Vanishing twins
Researchers suspect that as many as 1 in 8 pregnancies start out as multiples, but only a single fetus is brought to full term because the other fetus has died very early in the pregnancy and has not been detected or recorded. Early obstetric ultrasonography exams sometimes reveal an “extra” fetus, which fails to develop and instead disintegrates and vanishes in the uterus. There are several reasons for the “vanishing” fetus, including it being embodied or absorbed by the other fetus, placenta or the mother. This is known as vanishing twin syndrome. Also, in an unknown proportion of cases, two zygotes may fuse soon after fertilization, resulting in a single chimeric embryo and, later, a fetus.
Putting it together: Research on Twins
Twin Studies
Using the features of height and spoken language as examples, let’s take a look at how nature and nurture apply: identical twins, unsurprisingly, are almost perfectly similar in height. The heights of fraternal twins, however, are like any other sibling pairs: more similar to each other than to people from other families, but hardly identical. This contrast between twin types gives us a clue about the role genetics plays in determining height.
Now consider spoken language. If one identical twin speaks Spanish at home, the co-twin with whom she is raised almost certainly does, too. But the same would be true for a pair of fraternal twins raised together. In terms of spoken language, fraternal twins are just as similar as identical twins, so it appears that the genetic match of identical twins doesn’t make much difference.
Twin and adoption studies are two instances of a much broader class of methods for observing nature-nurture called quantitative genetics, the scientific discipline in which similarities among individuals are analyzed based on how biologically related they are. We can do these studies with siblings and half-siblings, cousins, and twins who have been separated at birth and raised separately (Bouchard et al., 1990). Such twins are very rare and play a smaller role than is commonly believed in the science of nature nurture or with entire extended families (Plomin et al., 2012).
It would be satisfying to be able to say that nature-nurture studies have given us conclusive and complete evidence about where traits come from, with some traits clearly resulting from genetics and others almost entirely from environmental factors, such as child-rearing practices and personal will, but that is not the case. Instead, everything has turned out to have some footing in genetics. The more genetically-related people are, the more similar they are—for everything: height, weight, intelligence, personality, mental illness, etc. Sure, it seems like common sense that some traits have a genetic bias. For example, adopted children resemble their biological parents even if they have never met them, and identical twins are more similar to each other than are fraternal twins. And while certain psychological traits, such as personality or mental illness (e.g., schizophrenia), seem reasonably influenced by genetics, it turns out that the same is true for political attitudes, how much television people watch (Plomin et al., 1990), and whether or not they get divorced (McGue & Lykken, 1992).
Attributions
Human Growth and Development by Ryan Newton is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License,
Individual and Family Development, Health, and Well-being by Diana Lang, Nick Cone; Laura Overstreet, Stephanie Loalada; Suzanne Valentine-French, Martha Lally; Julie Lazzara, and Jamie Skow is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License,
Human Development by Human Development Teaching & Learning Group under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License,
References
Berk, L. (2004). Development through the life span (3rd ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Bortolus, R., Parazzini, F., Chatenoud, L., Benzi, G., Bianchi, M. M., & Marini, A. (1999). The epidemiology of multiple births. Human Reproduction Update, 5, 179-187.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2015) Genetic Counseling. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/genetics/genetic_counseling.html
Fraga, M. F., Ballestar, E., Paz, M. F., Ropero, S., Setien, F., Ballestar, M. L., Heine-Suñer, D., Cigudosa, J. C., Urioste, M., Benitez, J., Boix-Chornet, M., Sanchez-Aguilera, A., Ling, C., Carlsson, E., Poulsen, P., Vaag, A., Stephan, Z., Spector, T. D., Wu, Y.-Z., … Esteller, M. (2005). Epigenetic differences arise during the lifetime of monozygotic twins. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 102(30), 10604–10609. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0500398102
Gottlieb, G. (2002). Individual development and evolution: The genesis of novel behavior. New York: Oxford University Press.
Gould, J. L., & Keeton, W. T. (1997). Biological science (6th ed.). New York: Norton.
Leve, L. D., Neiderhiser, J. M., Scaramella, L. V., & Reiss, D. (2010). The early growth and development study: using the prospective adoption design to examine genotype-environment interplay. 2008. Behavior Genetics, 40(3), 306–314. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10519-010-9353-1
McKusick, V. A. (1998). Mendelian inheritance in man: A catalog of human genes and genetic disorders. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
National Institute of Health (2015). An overview of the human genome project. http://www.genome.gov/12011238
Plomin, R., DeFries, J. C., Knopik, V. S., & Niederhiser, J. M. (2013). Behavioral Genetics (6th edition). NY: Worth Publishers.