6.1.3 Weak Points and Counterarguments

Argument: If immunity can be achieved naturally without vaccines, then why are vaccines necessary?

Rebuttal: While immunity can be achieved naturally, it may not be the smartest option for some people, such as children, the elderly, those with underlying health conditions, etc. Vaccines are more efficient because they prevent illness or strongly reduce symptoms. They are standardized and administered in a controlled and safe environment. 

Argument: Vaccinations are only created so that for-profit medical companies can take advantage of the situation for their own gain.

Rebuttal: The medical professionals who create the vaccines have values and regulations that they must follow in order to test and approve the vaccine. These professionals are working in the best interest of society and would not encourage vaccination if it was not up to standard.

Argument: Vaccine mandates and legislation limit a person’s right to choose and have bodily autonomy.

Rebuttal: Vaccine mandates are set in place for the greater good of society. Political propaganda on various media platforms creates warped ideas about the purpose of vaccine mandates, swaying people on whether or not to follow them. Everyone has the fundamental right to bodily autonomy and to make their own healthcare decisions. However, since these rights are not absolute, they do not include the right to inflict harm on others. Therefore, vaccines are a justifiable intrusion on an individual’s autonomy.